Which Is the Best Electric Screwdriver? Mechanopedia’s Top Picks

Using a screwdriver to secure screws over and over again is certainly one of the most mundane tasks when it comes to DIY projects. This is why purchasing the best electric screwdriver is an investment you’ll never regret as it will cut a lot of hassle and make this process much more convenient. It’s like getting the best battery trimmer to take care of your garden, if you know what we mean.

However, before you decide to buy this product, you must be informed about what criteria to use to identify the best electric screwdriver for you. This is far from being easy though especially if you don’t know what exactly you’re looking for, as there is a broad spectrum of features such a product might come with. Moreover, manufacturers aren’t helping much since they advertise every little positive thing about their product no matter how insignificant it is.

This problem is precisely what inspired us to write this article, and we’ve gone through numerous products in order to bring you only the best among them. Moreover, we included a buying guide to take you through the whole process.

So, all you have to do is read through our reviews, and we are sure you’ll find just the right product that’ll suit your needs.

RECOMMENDED
DEWALT DCF610S2 12-Volt Max 1/4-Inch Screwdriver Kit
WORX WX255L SD Semi-Automatic Power Screw Driver with Screw Holder
BUDGET OPTION
BLACK+DECKER 4V MAX Cordless Screwdriver (BDCS20C)
SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V Max Lithium-Ion Palm-Sized Cordless Screwdriver
Bosch Go 3.6V Smart Cordless Screwdriver
DEWALT DCF610S2 12-Volt Max 1/4-Inch Screwdriver Kit
WORX WX255L SD Semi-Automatic Power Screw Driver with Screw Holder
BLACK+DECKER 4V MAX Cordless Screwdriver (BDCS20C)
SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V Max Lithium-Ion Palm-Sized Cordless Screwdriver
Bosch Go 3.6V Smart Cordless Screwdriver
from $94.85
$35.56
$16.55
$49.99
$56.99
RECOMMENDED
DEWALT DCF610S2 12-Volt Max 1/4-Inch Screwdriver Kit
DEWALT DCF610S2 12-Volt Max 1/4-Inch Screwdriver Kit
from $94.85
WORX WX255L SD Semi-Automatic Power Screw Driver with Screw Holder
WORX WX255L SD Semi-Automatic Power Screw Driver with Screw Holder
$35.56
BUDGET OPTION
BLACK+DECKER 4V MAX Cordless Screwdriver (BDCS20C)
BLACK+DECKER 4V MAX Cordless Screwdriver (BDCS20C)
$16.55
SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V Max Lithium-Ion Palm-Sized Cordless Screwdriver
SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V Max Lithium-Ion Palm-Sized Cordless Screwdriver
$49.99
Bosch Go 3.6V Smart Cordless Screwdriver
Bosch Go 3.6V Smart Cordless Screwdriver
$56.99

The Best Electric Screwdriver – Our Picks

#1 – DEWALT DCF610S2 12V Electric Screwdriver Kit

This product is the first on our list, and it wouldn’t have been at that place without reason: everyone who uses this tool agrees that its power makes it the best electric screwdriver around. It is so powerful it’s akin to a drill, which is an exceptional feat from the manufacturer.

One of the best features that come with the DEWALT DCF610S2 12V is the dual batteries which enable it to work for an extended time, requiring little charging stops even without an extra battery. This further proves its status as one of the best electric screwdrivers. Another neat feature is LED lights that eliminate dark areas as inconvenient working conditions.

The portability of this product is excellent as it sits at just 2.2 pounds with its battery included, putting no strain whatsoever when carried around. Moreover, it has a useful hook on the belt for even more convenience.

The only drawback of this product is that a small percentage of released units come with a chuck that is highly prone to breaking. Even though this generally happens while the warranty’s duration is not yet over, it might still be a hassle to deal with.

All in all, the DEWALT DCF610S2 12V is an outstanding package of features in addition to portability and power that makes it one of the best electric screwdrivers on the market, with most buyers satisfied by their purchase.

What we like about it

What we adore about this product is that it is a complete package with little to no drawbacks. It sports high power, coupled with user convenience and additional features. This tool is undoubtedly the best electric screwdriver, and we highly recommend it for you.

#2 – WORX WX255L Power Screw Driver

This is the best electric screwdriver to go for if you are on a budget. The WORX WX255L SD Semi-Automatic costs only 40% of the price of the previously reviewed product; thus, it isn’t a substantial investment at all. Moreover, what it offers is outstanding for the cost.

The features of this product are what cements its status among the best electric screwdrivers on the market. First of all, a convenient feature is the holder attachment which enables you to hold both the tool and the screw along with it with a single hand, allowing you to keep the other one free to do other stuff during the process.   

Another must-have addition is the light that lets you work in poorly lighted areas with no problems. This review wouldn’t have been complete without the mention of the bit holder with a maximum capacity of six bits. This godsend lets you change bits on the fly when you are rapidly evolving between screws that have different heads.

The only thing that keeps this particular product from taking the top spot on our list is the slow charging that takes long, frustrating hours. Otherwise, this is the best electric screwdriver in terms of power to price ratio, and we recommend it to you if you can tolerate its only obvious flaw.

What we like about it

What we like the most about the WORX WX255L are the many extra features that make convenience an appealing characteristic of this model. Moreover, for a product that is this comfortable to use and yields such a power, it has an excellent price that isn’t heavy on one’s budget. This is why we can easily rank it as the second-best electric screwdriver.

#3 – BLACK+DECKER BDCS20C Electric Screw-Driver

If you are looking for one of the best electric screwdrivers while also on a budget, then this is another product that might suit your needs. Actually, you can get it for a far lower price than the two products we already reviewed. This is a compromise of some features and power of course, and it’s up to you to make a choice.

The best trait of the BLACK+DECKER BDCS20C is that it’s very compact; thus, you can maneuver into any space large to fit your hand. Moreover, it offers good power for such a size reaching up to 35 inch-pounds, which is relatively respectable. These traits are what puts it on the list of the best electric screwdrivers on the market.

The LED light is missing from this model, which might cut usability when compared to the competitors that have this feature. Furthermore, the manufacturers chose such a weird place for the forward/reverse button, which might be problematic.

This model is a cheap alternative to pricier, more feature-filled products. This comes at a compromise of convenience, but it might just be the right sacrifice to make if you are looking for a product that will do occasional work. This is why it is the best electric screwdriver in the budget-friendly category.

What we like about it

We love that this is the best electric screwdriver when it comes to cost, as it is the cheapest variant by far. This is coupled with respectable power and convenient size, so you can use it to handle your needs if you only have the occasional screws that need to be secured. This is why we recommend it for home users who don’t have much work and need just the minimum to achieve the desired result.

#4 – SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V Lithium-Ion

Similarly to the previous mention, this model comes at a pretty reasonable price, making it another option in the budget category. A particular exciting trait of the SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V is the modern design that might be a little too sleek for this type of tools.

The beloved LED light comes back with this product, which is an advantage relative to the previous mention. Moreover, it has a handy battery gauge that indicates when you’ll need to charge your battery and how much you got left. The feature that sets it apart from the competition, however, is the USB charging cable with which you can recharge the tool with your car or laptop, which further bolsters its portability. These features only come with one of the best electric screwdrivers on the market.

The drawback of this model includes the slow charging time with the USB cable unless you use the provided adapter. Additionally, it only works well on easy tasks, with problems starting to appear when ramping up the difficulty.

All in all, this product figures on this list as one of the best electric screwdrivers thanks to its combination of low price and useful features. Thus, you may regard it as a substitute for the previous product on our list.

What we like about it

What we like the most about the SKIL 2354-07 iXO 4V is much like the BLACK+DECKER BDCS20C, a cheap tool that provides excellent features instead of good power in this case. This makes it equally the best electric screwdriver in the lower price range. Thus, we recommend it as an alternative if you are for a model that will handle the occasional easy jobs you might encounter.

#5 – Bosch Go 3.6V Smart Cordless Screwdriver Set

This is a great model for those who are just starting this type of work as it comes with a generous set of 33 bits, which will make for an excellent expansion of your bit collection. Another useful feature is an intelligent E-clutch that rapidly halts the tool when releasing the trigger. This makes it the best electric screwdriver for beginners.

This model is priced higher than expected for what it offers, as the excellent quality and features don’t justify such a high investment. Moreover, this is yet another model that necessitates USB charging. It might be handy if you’re charging on the go, but otherwise, it is a hassle to deal with, especially since the charger is designed for European plugs.

All in all, this product lacks in features that might make such a high cost worthwhile, especially since it doesn’t have a light or any of the plethora of other useful perks competing tools have. 

What we like about it

What we like about this model is that it is the best electric screwdriver for amateur users since it offers a vast collection of bits, so you don’t have any trouble while dealing with any type of screw head. 

Choosing the Best Electric screwdriver – Buying Guide

If you still have some confusion over which product you’re going to pick, don’t worry as this is totally normal. All of the different features and prices makes the process even harder, especially figuring what to consider the most.

So, we’ll be going through the important aspects to consider when checking the best electrical screwdrivers. Read through to know how to get the best deal you can get your hands on.

Battery Type

The most common battery type for these tools is lithium-ion, and the best electric screwdrivers belong to this category. This is because they beat the nickel-cadmium batteries in most aspects, especially since they can store a lot more energy for the size. Thanks to that, you can always win in terms of weight while keeping the same level of power.

 There is also another problem with the latter variant, as they tend to develop a “memory.” This happens when you charge them while they aren’t entirely empty, so they start to lose power starting from this point instead of when they’re empty.

In conclusion, you should go with li-ion batteries as they are the superior type in almost every way, with no drawbacks whatsoever.

Motor Type

Generally, the best electric screwdrivers have brushless motors installed. Prior to this type, brushed motors were used. This variant required brushes, which is an energy-inefficient component that necessitated regular maintenance due to the friction which wears them out.

On the other hand, brushless motors don’t need this part, so there’s far less friction involved. Another advantage of this is that the engine becomes much more efficient in terms of energy consumption since there’s no more heat-related loss and there’s a gain in weight. This is why you should go the brushless route to get a better, lighter tool, like all the best electric screwdrivers.

Weight

In this department, the cordless type wins because they generally don’t weigh too much but can still deliver the right power. This is all thanks to the lithium-ion batteries and brushless motors, which enables the tool to weigh as little as two pounds.

The best electric screwdrivers have a weight of the range between five and seven pounds, which makes them convenient enough that they don’t put a strain on one’s hands and arms while working in constrained spaces. 

Just make sure that your product isn’t too heavy since then you can get a drill instead and have far more power for the weight. Of course, getting one of the best screwdrivers is guaranteed to give you this result.

Extra Features

Some perks that don’t increase the price by much but otherwise greatly enhance the user experience include the onboard bit storage. Even though this might make the tool a bit heavy, it is really worthwhile if you’re working with different headed screws in rapid succession. This is why most of the best electric screwdrivers come with this advantage.

Another nice feature is a screw-holder that fixes the screw head on the bit, and this is especially useful when you’re changing between screws rapidly. Finally, the best electric screwdrivers have a LED light to allow working in the darkest areas, since this is not uncommon to encounter during this type of work.

Choosing the Right One

A suboptimal strategy many people go by is to either bye the priciest model they can find, or pick the cheapest one and hope for the best. Even though this might sometimes work, guaranteeing a great deal needs a much more efficient thinking stream.

You first should imagine how you would often use your tool. Then, deduce the features that you must get in order to fulfill your need. Now make a list of devices that come with those perks, and pick the cheapest one from them. This way, you’ll get the best electric screwdriver for your needs that will cost as little as possible.

Picking the Best Electric screwdriver – Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Choose an Electric screwdriver, a Drill Or an Impact Driver?

This is an essential question since these tools often overlap in usage. However, each one has a niche that sets it apart from the other two. Moreover, there isn’t much difference when it comes to the investment you’ll have to make, so you better know which one to go with according to your needs.

Electric Screwdriver

This is the tool to get for this specific need as it will any job a regular screwdriver does, so you should handle them as such. They’re exactly like them albeit automatic. Moreover, most of them don’t include a clutch for control. Even though their use is restricted to this one task, they can significantly speed up the process.

Drill

This is the tool most users are accustomed to since they are all-around useful in many jobs. They weigh more though but have more power; thus, they can handle situations even the best electric screwdrivers can’t. They are an effective tool thanks to some useful features like a clutch and speed triggers that are variable.

Impact Driver

This is the more obscure tool of the bunch that is close to the impact wrench. Its primary function is to eliminate lug nuts, and for that, it’s capable of dishing out a high torque in a short time. The main perk relative to the other two types is that they’re lighter and capable of working longer on the same charge.

Verdict

In conclusion, these were the top five best electric screwdrivers on the market currently, so you can comfortably limit your choice between them. In the end, the choice between price, power, and features is in your hands, and you should make your pick according to your needs.

No matter which one you end up buying among those on this list, rest assured that it is the best electric screwdriver in its category. And if you still have any confusion, you should follow our buying guide which will take you through the whole thinking process.

Sorry, fellow craftsman, but you have no excuse now, so get on with the purchase already!

References:

  • https://www.popularmechanics.com/home/tools/reviews/a3119/cordless-drill-driver-vs-impact-driver-which-do-you-need-14583956/
  • https://www.homedepot.com/c/ab/impact-drivers-vs-drills/9ba683603be9fa5395fab9009f66e37
  • Our own experience